Portico, portico, who's got the portico?

or, How the Donnell House Portico came back home to New Bern

By John B. Green III

Peter B. Sandbeck and John B. Green III, portico porters, 1985.

In a previous post (Vanished New Bern, No.3) we described the destruction of the John R. Donnell House and the scattering of its various parts.

The John R. Donnell House was perhaps New Bern's finest residence of the Federal Period.   Constructed for Judge Donnell between 1816 and 1819, the house and adjacent law office displayed the handiwork of Asa King, New Bern's premier builder of that time.  The house was quadrupled in size by a three-story apartment building addition to the rear in the 1920s and throughout much of the 20th century was known as the Hughes Apartments.  A spectacular fire on January 24, 1970 destroyed the apartment house addition and damaged the original house.  The Donnell house was stripped of its fine architectural details and demolished following the fire.  Some of the interior woodwork was taken to Mobile, Alabama and used in the construction of a new home, while the front portico and other elements were taken to Charlotte.  The Donnell law office was moved intact to nearby Trent Woods.   After many years of storage, the Donnell House portico was returned to New Bern in April 1985 and is now displayed in the New Bern Academy Museum.

John R. Donnell House and Office, 712 Craven Street, photo c. 1965.

The paragraph above makes it seem as though the location of the Judge Donnell portico had always been known, yet such was not the case.  Although it was generally remembered that various architectural elements of the Donnell house had been sold away from New Bern, the fate of the portico had been all but forgotten.  So it came as quite a surprise to the members of the New Bern Historical Society when Dr. C. Hal Chaplin of Charlotte, North Carolina contacted the society in 1985 with news of the portico.  He informed them that he had the portico and would like to return it to New Bern.  Dr. Chaplin had purchased the portico and other woodwork in 1970 with the intention of incorporating the material into a new house he was building.  He never used the portico and it was stored in pieces in his garage where his children played on and under it.

Donnell House portico in situ, 1936. Photo by Frances Benjamin Johnston.

After some discussion (What do we with do with a portico?), Dr. Chaplin's kind offer was accepted and a crack team of professional portico porters was assembled (Peter B. Sandbeck and John B. Green III).  Dispatched on April 21, 1985 in a truck borrowed from Askew's Hardware, the intrepid pair made their way to Charlotte, loaded up the portico, posed for a photograph (see above) and returned to New Bern the next day.  Once in New Bern they drove the portico up Craven Street to its former site, then out National Avenue and Oaks Road to a disused dairy barn owned by Mr. F. Murray Phillips where the portico was to be stored.  The Donnell portico would remain there for nearly two years before a permanent home was found for it.

Donnell House portico as displayed in the New Bern Academy Museum, 1990.

In February 1987 the New Bern Historical Society donated the portico to the Tryon Palace Historic Sites and Gardens for display in the New Bern Academy Museum.  The portico made one final trip from the dairy barn to the Academy where, over the next three years, it was studied, reassembled, and restored.  The Donnell House portico became the centerpiece of the architectural history room of the Academy museum when it opened in December 1990.  The portico had finally returned to public view after an absence of twenty years.

The house that was cut in half

or, Half a house is better than none?

By John B. Green III

Photocopy of sketch of the Cole House dated June 1885. New Bern Craven County Public Library.

The Cole House once stood on the north side of the 500 block of Pollock Street.  Probably dating from the first quarter of the 19th century, the house was acquired by James Carney Cole in 1858 for his residence.  Cole and his family remained in New Bern during the Union army occupation and he died during the great yellow fever epidemic of 1864.  The property passed to his daughter Mary Catherine Cole.  It was during the ownership of Miss Cole that the house began its piecemeal progression to demolition.  Some time in the late 1890s the house was enlarged to the west and converted to a duplex with a second entrance and porch added.

Detail of 1898 Sanborn Insurance Map of New Bern showing the Cole House converted to a duplex.

Mary Catherine Cole sold the property to her sister Lavinia Cole Roberts (Mrs. Frederick C. Roberts) in 1904.  In 1910 the Roberts sold a portion of the property containing the old Cole House to their daughter Annie Roberts Boyd (Mrs. W.G. Boyd).  The Boyds proceeded to demolish the eastern half of the Cole House.  They are said to have reused some of the materials from the Cole House in the new house which they constructed on the eastern portion of the lot between May 1910 and January 1911.  The remaining western half of the Cole House was repaired and retained as a rental property.

Surviving western half of the Cole House, photo ca. 1950. N.C. Division of Archives & History.

The Boyds sold the 1911 house to D.W. Hanks in 1923.  It was demolished ca. 1970.  The western half of the Cole House lived on until 1968 when it was purchased from the Boyd heirs by the New Bern Historical Society.  The society demolished the structure to make way for a new rear driveway to their headquarters building, the Attmore-Oliver House.

Loose cannons

By John B. Green III

Photo, ca. 1935, of cannons at intersection of Middle and Pollock streets.

Most towns of New Bern's age manage to accumulate the spare cannon or two.  Relics of bygone conflicts, they are re-purposed as monuments and ornaments in parks and cemeteries.  New Bern has four cannons on public view, each with an interesting history of use and abuse.

Photo, ca. 1935, of the "Lady Blessington" cannon.

The longest on public display is the so-called "Lady Blessington" cannon and its now relocated companion.  Dating from the 18th century, they are said to have been captured from the British during the American Revolution.  The cannon closest to the Episcopal churchyard fence has been known as the "Lady Blessington" since at least the 1880s.  It was declared to be such by both of New Bern's 19th century historians, Col. John D. Whitford and Rev. Lachlan C. Vass, who agreed that it had been captured by one of New Bern merchant John Wright Stanly's privateers.  Both indicate that the cannon, with others, was from an armed British vessel financed or sponsored by a Lady Blessington.  A 1901 newspaper article even states that the name "Lady Blessington" was once visible on the breech of the gun but had been worn away.  Unfortunately, the British vessel has never been identified and no Lady Blessington is known from the Revolutionary war era.

A second legend attached to the "Lady Blessington" cannon concerns its odd placement - muzzle buried in the ground.  Col. John D. Whitford is again the authority.  Writing in 1904 he states that when the surveyor Jonathan Price was hired in 1810 to produce a new survey of the town "the cannon was carried and then set up, where it is now, as a starting point for Price in his survey."  The minutes of the town commissioners do record Price being hired on April 26, 1809 "to run off and survey the Town  of New Bern and to establish such corners of squares, as near the original plan of the said Town as possible."  One year later the commissioners ordered that Price "be paid the sum of Two hundred & fifty dollars for his services in Surveying the Town - fixing the Corner stones, making two plans of the town, with notes etc."  Alas, no mention is made of Price being ordered to bury a cannon up to its trunnions for use as a benchmark.

The cannon's 20th century history is marked by only two events of note.  When the Episcopalians erected the present wrought and cast iron fence around their churchyard in 1902, the "Lady Blessington" cannon was revered enough, and enough of an immovable object, that the fence was caused to curve around the gun.  And in May 1928 the Richard Dobbs Spaight Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution embedded a small bronze tablet in the sidewalk in front of the cannon which recounted the traditional history of the gun.

Photo, c. 1935, of "Lady Blessington" cannon and companion in its drinking fountain phase.

From the 1890s onward, and possibly much earlier, the "Lady Blessington" cannon had a companion in the form of a smaller gun located approximately ten feet closer to the street and likewise buried muzzle down.  It can be seen in the circa 1900 photograph and enlarged detail below.

Photograph and enlarged detail, c. 1900, of corner of Middle and Pollock streets.

It may have been part of Jonathan Price's survey of the town although only one cannon is mentioned by later historians.  While this cannon's history prior to the 20th century is hazy at best, its later history is better known.  In June 1916 the cannon was temporarily removed so that a hole could be bored through the side of the tube and another hole drilled through the cascabel to accommodate a city water pipe.  It was then replanted, muzzle down, in the sidewalk, and a small bowl and faucet was attached to convert the gun into a drinking fountain.  By the 1960s the cannon had been removed from the street and reappeared, minus its plumbing, on a concrete base at Union Point park.  After suffering vandalism and an attempted theft, the gun disappeared into city storage.  It was rediscovered in 1988 and loaned to the New Bern Academy Museum where it was restored and placed on display in July 1991.

"Drinking Fountain" cannon arriving at Tryon Palace conservation lab Sept 30, 1988.

Cannon in Tryon Palace conservation lab Sept 30, 1988.  Hole for 1916 water line visible in cascabel.

The early history of New Bern's third cannon is likewise unknown although it history from Tuesday February 18, 1930 onward is well documented by the local newspapers.  On that date, workmen excavating the foundation trenches for the new McLellan store at the southwest corner of Middle and Pollock streets, struck the buried cannon.  It was at a depth of eighteen inches beneath the surface and was grown over with trees and brush.  As news of the find spread, Mrs. Richard Nixon Duffy, president of the New Bern Historical Society, requested that the cannon be given to her organization for display.  Mr. H.W. Hendricks, superintendent for the Goode Construction Company, whose workmen had discovered the gun, readily agreed to her request.  Mayor H.G. Tolson dispatched a city truck to remove the cannon and the historical society began to lay plans for the gun's display.  Mrs. Duffy initially proposed that the cannon be mounted on the Craven County Courthouse green but this plan eventually fell through.  It was not until June 1933 that the cannon found a permanent home.

Photo, c.1933, of the East Front Street cannon.

A site along the newly landscaped East Front Street waterfront had been agreed upon and the cannon was to be mounted on an architect-designed base.  The architect was Adolph Witschard of New York City, who was residing in New Bern.  Mr. Witschard designed a base of local shell rock ornamented with cannon balls and draped with anchor chains.  The base was soon completed and the cannon duly mounted.

"Tryon Palace Cannon" historical marker, East Front Street.

Since its discovery three years earlier, the cannon had acquired a remarkable history.  After much speculation, it had been decided that the ancient gun was probably one of the six cannons removed from Tryon Palace by the New Bern Committee of Safety in June 1775.  Speculation became "fact" with the erection of a decorative marker adjacent to the cannon which proclaimed that it was a "Tryon Palace Cannon."

The historical marker is long gone and the shell rock and anchor chain base for the cannon was destroyed during the refurbishing of the East Front Street park 1999-2000.  The old cannon is still to be seen there although now mounted on a plain granite base.

The fourth and last cannon on our tour has a history as murky as all the rest.  Found somewhere in New Bern in the 1950s, it came into possession of the City of New Bern who donated it to the Tryon Palace Commission.  Mounted on a reproduction naval gun carriage, designed with assistance from the Smithsonian Institution, the cannon was placed on a brick platform on the south lawn of the Palace.  There it was dedicated on September 17, 1961 and fired by a U.S. Marine Corps gun crew.

18th century cannon, South Lawn, Tryon Palace, photo c.1965